Cards › 1958 Topps Willie Mays #486 All Star
Is the 1958 Topps Willie Mays #486 All Star worth grading?
Live market numbers as of 2026-10-21 — raw vs. graded value, PSA 10 gem rate, and the breakeven math.
Raw value
$71.91
PSA 9 value
$2,225.79
PSA 10 value
$14,800.62
PSA 10 gem rate
0%
Based on the numbers below, this card is potentially worth grading — a PSA 10 nets an estimated $12,418, but the 0% gem rate means the 10 is far from guaranteed. Weigh the PSA 9 outcome below.
The breakeven math
| Line item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Raw purchase | $71.91 |
| Sales tax (8%) | $5.75 |
| Grading fee (priority tier) | $80.00 |
| Shipping | $5.00 |
| Total cost basis | $162.66 |
| Net at PSA 10 (85% payout) | +$12,417.86 (+7634%) |
| Net at PSA 9 (the downside case) | +$1,729.26 |
Assumptions: $80 grading, $5 shipping, 8% tax on the raw purchase, and keeping 85% of the sale after marketplace fees. Your numbers will differ — run them below.
Run this card with YOUR costs
Set your own grading tier, tax rate, and payout — then screen the entire catalog for cards that beat this one. Free for 14 days, no credit card.
Start free trialCard pricing data provided by SportsCardsPro, a service of PriceCharting. Gem rates reflect recent PSA population data. Not investment advice — grading outcomes are probabilistic and markets move. © Summit Sports Cards · About · Pricing